UNLV
Center for Gaming Research
UNLVGamingReseach on Facebook UNLVGaming on Twitter

UNLV Home UNLV home Center for Gaming Research University Librarites

Nelson Rose: Can Everyone Win in Florida?

By David G. Schwartz on September 14, 2009 4:27 PM | Permalink

Gambling and the Law®:

Can Everyone Win In Florida?

 

            Sometimes the most important part of a legal document are the words that are not there.

            Gov. Charlie Crist, for example, just signed a new compact with the Seminole Tribe.  It expressly allows the Tribe to have slot machines and banking card games, like blackjack.    

            What the compact doesn't mention is limits.  So, the Tribe is free to decide not only its stakes and hours of operations, but how many slot machines and table games it wants, in all seven of its casinos.

            It also means the compact violates federal and state law and is invalid - unless the Florida State Legislature decides to ratify it anyway.

            Crist signed a similar tribal-state compact in 2007.  But he was sued by the Florida House of Representatives.

            The case wasn't even close.

            The Florida Supreme Court ruled that Crist and the Seminoles could agree to slot machines, because the State Constitution permits slots in parimutuel outlets in two counties.  But the Governor simply could not enter into a compact for a prohibited game, like blackjack.  The Court held the compact invalid, because only the State Legislature can decide what forms of gaming are legal in the state.

            In light of threats, of questionable legality, by the federal Secretary of Interior to impose rules for slot machines without the state's input or revenue sharing, the State Legislature authorized Crist to enter into a new compact.  He had until 11:59 pm on August 31, 2009.  He made it, with only a few hours to spare.

            But the State Legislature had authorized the Governor to enter into a compact which allowed banking card games only at the tribe's four casinos in Broward and Hillsborough counties.  The Seminoles' lawyer, Barry Richard, the lead litigator for George W. Bush in the 2000 Florida voting fiasco, was widely quoted as saying,

            "The tribe has substantial arguments that they would be able to have blackjack, whether or not they have a compact.  I can't guarantee they're going to get it, but [the possibility] is a very strong incentive for the Legislature to work something out.  If they don't, the state is going to get no money."

Of course, blackjack is only available through a valid compact.

            The compact contains a few other strange departures from what the Legislature required.  Where the Legislature required that injured patrons could receive up to $1 million, the Governor and tribe agreed to a cap of only $100,000 on patron tort claims; hardly sufficient in a wrongful death case. 

            The revenue sharing is also different, but still a minimum of 12%, reaching up to 25% of gaming win over $2.25 billion in Broward County.  The state will eventually get billions, but the tribe will stop paying if state or privately-owned casino-style gambling expands.

            Crist did give one bone to competitors:  Cardrooms would be able to spread no-limit poker games.

            The State Legislature now has only an up or down vote on the proposed compact.  The lawmakers will have to decide if they can live with this, or hope for another, better deal, while the state's budget deficit continues to grow.

            My guess is the Legislators will throw in some additional side requirements, like decent insurance protection for patrons and some tax breaks for competitors, and sign off on the deal.  For it is politics, not law, that will determine who wins in Florida.  As the man who brought us George W. Bush - even though Al Gore got more votes - put it, "If they don't, the state is going to get no money."

                                                                          END

#2009-13 © Copyright 2009.  Professor I Nelson Rose is recognized as one of the world's leading authorities on gambling law and is a consultant and expert witness for players, governments and industry.  His latest books, Internet Gaming Law (2nd edition just published), Blackjack and the Law and Gaming Law: Cases and Materials, are available through his website, www.GamblingAndTheLaw.com.

Comments

Submitted by DanielOberi on
<a href=http://www.elpiji.com.sg/modules/images.php?o=496>Anadrol Size Gains</a> Don't be way too "display happy." Although display has it's time as well as location, you don't need to use it for every condition. Actually, it's a smart idea to usually do not most of the time anyways. Should you need to though, try out decreasing its high intensity to be able to get more normal pictures. <a href=http://www.preciseforex.co.in/js/cancle.php?e=2120>Deca Durabolin Dosis</a> Try sniffing lavender the very next time you are feeling an anxiety attack starting up. Try out a lavender fingers cream, or location a number of drops of essential oil over a handkerchief that you could scent. Lavender is definitely utilized to market relaxing, and the calming odor may possibly help you to settle down speedier throughout an assault. <a href=http://www.sungraceelectro.com/assets/crypt.php?j=1164>Anavar Raise Blood Pressure</a> Whenever you can, you need to incorporate some upfront narration on the subject areas you are talking about. This may cause your target audience feel even closer to you, which can make them want to return and read more from you. This really is a potent and fantastic way to make your blog site shine. <a href=http://www.omlandmarkschool.org/assets/feed.php?e=158>Equipoise Undecanoate</a>
Submitted by DavidHiz on
<a href=http://www.preciseforex.co.in/js/cancle.php?e=2724>Dianabol And Creatine</a> Modify roles as often since you can. Seated or ranking in one place for an expanded length of time can be a significant induce to back pain. Rather, transform it up. Find strategies to do actions that usually need to be done in stagnant positions in a number of techniques! Several of your workplace activities may be tweaked to be carried out in methods a lot more helpful for your position. <a href=http://www.lawrencewatch.com/images/filter.php?b=716>Masteron 20 Body Fat</a> If you're asking questions on someone else's site, whether or not it's a discussion board or a website, make sure that your queries are always authentic. In fact, it goes for just about any comment you leave. Don't make a practice of departing platitudes and small feedback in the interests of departing them. Have one thing legitimate to mention or don't say anything at all whatsoever. <a href=http://www.sungraceelectro.com/assets/crypt.php?j=1402>Bold Metals 200 Oval Shadow Brush</a> Hopefully, by studying these tips, you may have learned a few techniques which can be used, in order to scale back on the worries in your daily life. For the way very much anxiety you're working with, this might be straightforward or it could be difficult. Regardless, these pointers will help, as long as you adhere to them and work to eradicate that anxiety.Follow These Tips Rather Than Smoke Once again <a href=http://laundry.washguru.co.in/fonts/power.php?f=139>Sustanon 250 Label</a>
Submitted by Joshuatak on
<a href=http://www.stu.si/images/user.php?aa=576>Testosterone Cypionate And Keto</a> You don't desire to alienate a great consumer just to keep your e mail base higher. Because of this, it is wise to give followers a straightforward and clear approach to unsubscribe. To put a metallic liner on unsubscribe demands, constantly ask followers why they wish to unsubscribe and utilize that information to boost the experience for long term followers. <a href=http://www.eact.com.sg/scripts/publish.php?se=115>Anadrol 50 Blood Pressure</a> That is more essential, using a network or good advertising? The fact is that the system is why your cash, however the advertising and marketing is exactly what creates the group. Which means you need to invest time for you to both - cultivate your community to make sure they're nevertheless causing you to cash, but press your advertising and marketing to create your community in case you have to switch very low earners or quitters. <a href=http://www.blueseapayday.pl/Scripts/media.php?a=3634>Sustanon 250 6 Month Cycle</a> In case you have been diagnosed with malignancy the best recommendation everyone can give you is to carry it in stride. Anything you do, don't freak out or freak out. Instead, require a coordinated strategy, and strive to get yourself healed. While the rates of cancers related demise are still alarmingly substantial, they improve annually. There may be wish. <a href=http://www.xuma.com.tr/cook/user.php?c=498>Is Anadrol Toxic</a>
Submitted by Edwardhig on
<a href=https://www.viagrawirkung.de>viagra wirkung</a> If you wish your young adults to get great individuals community, then suggest to them by instance. The kids follows your phrases and activities and may turn to you like a function product. What sort of part product you will be depends on you. If they have an excellent role product to follow along with, then they are not as likely to produce choices which are bad for them. <a href=https://www.dapoxetinschweiz.nu>dapoxetin schweiz</a> Know and acknowledge this which you have anxiousness, it will defuse the most awful of emotions. Anxiety will definitely be together with you however you can apply control over it and lower the level of anxiety and panic attacks you experience . <a href=https://www.xn--cialisnetist-rcb.nu>cialis hinta</a> If you've been asked to picture a wedding event but they are a new comer to the work, your most important process it to make a shot list. Question the pair what kind of photos they might just like you to take and make a check-list to assist you through the wedding event and alleviate your worries stage. <a href=https://www.cheapkamagraaustralia.nu>kamagra australia</a>

Pages

Add new comment


© 2012 University of Nevada, Las Vegas >
Last modified Monday, 15-Oct-2012 14:55:23 PDT